Pictured here: The public defense of my thesis at the Yale School of the Environment.

Stewarding the Commons: How the Enclosure of British Common Lands between 1750-1850 Mirrors Today’s Enclosure of the Digital Commons

ABSTRACT

Before the British Enclosure Acts (1750-1850), Britain had vast plots of common lands, places of communal cultivation. Parliament called for the fencing of these commons through the Enclosure Acts. Lands became an acquirable asset that could be used to reinforce the power and prestige of landowners. I analyze the aesthetics and persuasive narratives that solidified hierarchical methods of resource control and access and which made enclosure seem like an ‘advancement.’ These aesthetics dismissed the disastrous effects that enclosure had on commoners who lost their rights to land that had been customarily understood as communal. I make an analogy to today’s AI revolution, asserting that AI is acting as an enclosure of the digital commons. While the digital commons exists in the abstract realm, and land commons in the realm of the physical, there remain parallels to be drawn between land enclosure and digital enclosure in that they both are shared resources consolidated without regard to communal custom. I defend the possibility of a commons being stewarded by challenging aesthetics and arguments that moralize the domination of shared resources, with the goal of supporting a form of resource sharing that acknowledges mutual obligations and common access.

This piece considers the role of artistic, rhetorical, and farming aesthetics and how they implicate and contribute to historical narratives about land. I argue that this history is relevant for today’s context of AI advancement.

Thanks to my thesis advisor, Margret Spillane; Director of Undergraduate Studies, Professor Fotos; the librarians, historians, priests, and theologians supporting this research: Kraig Binkowski, Father Gregory, Ben Crosby, and Jason Poling. Also, thanks to the Environmental Studies Department, which supported me with a fellowship in which I explored the intersection of morality, art, and environmentalism through a religious pilgrimage through Spain. This fellowship background informed the interdisciplinary method of research that was foundational to this thesis.

“History always constitutes the relation between the present and the past…the past is not for living in; it is a well of conclusions from which we draw in order to act.”

 - John Berger, Ways of Seeing

If you’d like to discuss some of these ideas, or access the text, please email me.